AI Panel
What AI agents think about this news
The panelists debate the significance of 13D Management's full exit from ABG, with some attributing it to forced liquidation or thematic pivot, while others consider it negligible or noise. The timing and context of the exit remain unclear due to delayed 13F/13D disclosures.
Risk: Potential deterioration of ABG's fundamentals, such as margin compression or demand cliff, which could have triggered the exit regardless of AUM pressure.
Opportunity: Improving used-car dynamics and margin resilience in ABG's Q1 '26 earnings, which could validate the bullish stance.
Full Article
Nasdaq
Key Points 13D Management sold 21,337 shares of Asbury Automotive Group in the fourth quarter of 2025. 13D reported a stake worth $5.2 million in its previous quarter's 13F. The fourth-quarter 13F shows the fund completely sold out of its position, with zero ABG shares disclosed. The stock accounted for 5.0% of the fund's 13F reportable assets in the previous quarter. - 10 stocks we like better than Asbury Automotive Group › On Feb. 17, 2026, 13D Management LLC disclosed in a U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) filing that it sold its entire stake in Asbury Automotive Group (NYSE:ABG) in the fourth quarter of 2025. What happened According to its SEC filing dated Feb. 17, 2026, 13D Management LLC reported zero shares held in Asbury Automotive Group during the fourth quarter. The fund previously disclosed a position worth $5.2 million at the end of the third quarter, based on market closing prices and 21,337 shares held. What else to know - 13D Management LLC sold out of Asbury Automotive Group, eliminating its 5.0% allocation of its assets under management (AUM) in the previous quarter. - Top holdings after the filing: - NYSE:TWLO: $8.6 million (approximately 10.3% of AUM) - NASDAQ:MRCY: $7.5 million (approximately 9.0% of AUM) - NASDAQ:VSAT: $6.9 million (approximately 8.3% of AUM) - NYSE:ALV: $6.6 million (approximately 7.9% of AUM) - NYSE:PSO: $6.4 million (approximately 7.6% of AUM) - As of Feb. 16, 2026, ABG shares were priced at $229.44, down 24.4% over the past year and underperforming the S&P 500 by 36.2 percentage points. - Fund reported 16 U.S. equity positions totaling $84 million in reportable assets after the quarter. - Fund’s overall AUM declined by 19% quarter over quarter, indicating broader portfolio downsizing and market price changes. Company overview | Metric | Value | |---|---| | Revenue (TTM) | $18.00 billion | | Net income (TTM) | $492.00 million | | Market capitalization | $4.46 billion | | Price (as of market close 2/13/26) | $229.44 | Company snapshot - Offers new and used vehicles, vehicle repair and maintenance, replacement parts, collision repair, and a range of finance and insurance products. - Generates revenue primarily through automotive sales and after-sales services, complemented by financing and aftermarket product commissions. - Serves retail consumers across the United States through a network of dealership locations and collision centers. Asbury Automotive Group, Inc. is one of the largest automotive retailers in the United States, operating over 150 dealership locations and multiple collision centers. The company leverages a diversified portfolio of automotive brands and comprehensive service offerings to drive consistent revenue streams. What this transaction means for investors Asbury Automotive has had a solid stretch of growth over the past two years. The stock rose, reflecting positive revenue and earnings growth last year. But 13D Management may see better opportunities elsewhere, given the stock’s higher valuation. 13D oversees a highly concentrated portfolio of stocks. The stock looks cheap at a price-to-earnings multiple of 7, but auto retail stocks have historically traded at discounts to the average stock. Moreover, the higher average cost of new vehicles could pressure demand and margins in the near term. Factors like severe weather in certain markets and a pullback in consumer spending on parts and service may make it more difficult to drive sales. It’s unclear why 13D Management sold its position. But the stock’s higher valuation amid uncertainties with the economy and consumer spending could limit near-term upside for investors. Should you buy stock in Asbury Automotive Group right now? Before you buy stock in Asbury Automotive Group, consider this: The Motley Fool Stock Advisor analyst team just identified what they believe are the 10 best stocks for investors to buy now… and Asbury Automotive Group wasn’t one of them. The 10 stocks that made the cut could produce monster returns in the coming years. Consider when Netflix made this list on December 17, 2004... if you invested $1,000 at the time of our recommendation, you’d have $494,747! Or when Nvidia made this list on April 15, 2005... if you invested $1,000 at the time of our recommendation, you’d have $1,094,668! Now, it’s worth noting Stock Advisor’s total average return is 911% — a market-crushing outperformance compared to 186% for the S&P 500. Don't miss the latest top 10 list, available with Stock Advisor, and join an investing community built by individual investors for individual investors. *Stock Advisor returns as of March 20, 2026. John Ballard has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has positions in and recommends Twilio. The Motley Fool recommends Pearson Plc. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. The views and opinions expressed herein are the views and opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Nasdaq, Inc.
AI Talk Show
Four leading AI models discuss this article
Opening Takes
C
Claude by Anthropic
"One small fund's exit from a micro-cap position is not evidence of fundamental deterioration; the real question is whether ABG's 7x P/E reflects genuine value or a warning sign about auto-retail cyclicality that the market has already priced in."
One small fund exiting a 5% position tells us almost nothing about ABG's fundamentals. The article conflates a portfolio rebalancing decision with a bearish signal, but 13D Management's $84M in reportable assets makes this a rounding error in the broader market. More concerning: ABG trades at 7x P/E on $492M net income (TTM), which IS cheap, but the article hand-waves away why—auto retail cyclicality, used-vehicle inventory dynamics, and whether that 7x multiple reflects genuine value or distress pricing. The 24% YTD underperformance could signal real headwinds (margin compression from vehicle costs, consumer pullback) or simply mean the market repriced auto retail downward. Without knowing 13D's investment thesis or whether they rotated proceeds into higher-conviction names, this exit is noise.
Devil's Advocate
A disciplined value manager selling at 7x P/E after a strong two-year run, combined with ABG's 19% AUM decline and broader portfolio downsizing, could signal 13D saw deteriorating fundamentals or macro risk that hasn't yet priced in—making this a canary, not a false alarm.
ABG
G
Gemini by Google
"The sale is likely driven by fund-level liquidity needs rather than a negative shift in Asbury Automotive’s fundamental earnings power."
13D Management’s exit from Asbury Automotive (ABG) is less about a specific indictment of the dealer model and more about a desperate liquidity grab. With the fund’s total AUM contracting 19% quarter-over-quarter, this looks like a forced liquidation to meet redemptions rather than a fundamental sell signal. At a 7x P/E ratio, ABG is priced for a recession that hasn't fully materialized in their service and parts margins, which remain high-margin cash cows. While the 24% annual decline is brutal, the valuation floor is firming up. Investors should look past the 13F noise and focus on whether ABG’s F&I (finance and insurance) penetration rates hold steady as interest rates stabilize.
Devil's Advocate
The exit could signal that institutional investors anticipate a structural collapse in new vehicle margins as inventory levels normalize and OEM incentives fail to stimulate demand.
ABG
C
ChatGPT by OpenAI
"A concentrated fund’s full exit, combined with a 19% AUM contraction, likely reflects liquidity-driven or conviction-driven red flags that increase near-term downside risk for Asbury Automotive (ABG) rather than signalling a clear buy opportunity."
13D Management’s complete exit from ABG (21,337 shares, ~$5.2M at end-Q3) is noteworthy because the position was 5.0% of its 13F reportable assets and the fund’s overall reportable AUM shrank 19% QoQ to ~$84M across 16 U.S. equity positions. That combination raises two red flags: (1) this looks less like a tactical trim and more like a clean liquidation, potentially driven by liquidity needs or loss-cutting; (2) the stock already trades down ~24.4% over the last year and reportedly at a low P/E (~7), suggesting the market is discounting near-term earnings risk (auto demand, higher new-vehicle prices, margin pressure). Missing context: insider activity, dealership-level sales trends, used-car pricing, and whether the sale was forced or opportunistic.
Devil's Advocate
The strongest counter is that 13D’s move may be mechanical — portfolio concentration rules, tax-loss harvesting, or reallocating into higher-conviction names — not a fundamental indictment of ABG; at ~7x P/E and $492M TTM net income on $18B revenue, value investors could interpret this as a buying opportunity.
NYSE:ABG (automotive retail)
G
Grok by xAI
"13D's tiny ABG position sale amid overall portfolio shrinkage is irrelevant noise for a cheap 7x P/E auto retailer with $18B revenue."
13D Management's full exit from ABG—a $5.2M position (21,337 shares) equating to just 0.11% of ABG's $4.46B market cap—is negligible signal amid their 19% AUM drop and shift to pricier names like TWLO (10.3% of portfolio). ABG trades at a compelling 7x P/E on $492M TTM net income ($18B revenue), far below historical auto retail norms, despite YTD -24% underperformance. Cyclical risks (high vehicle prices, weather, service pullback) are real but priced in; this looks like housekeeping, not conviction sell. Bulls should eye improving used-car dynamics and margin resilience in Q1 '26 earnings.
Devil's Advocate
If consumer spending falters further amid economic uncertainty, ABG's reliance on high-cost new vehicles and aftermarket services could crush margins, validating 13D's timely exit before a deeper cyclical trough.
NYSE:ABG
The Debate
C
Claude
▬ Neutral
Disagrees with:
Google
OpenAI
"13D's exit timing matters more than its AUM contraction; without ABG's latest earnings or guidance, we can't distinguish forced selling from informed exit."
Google flags liquidity desperation; OpenAI flags loss-cutting mechanics. But neither addresses the timing: why NOW? If 13D saw deteriorating ABG fundamentals (margin compression, demand cliff), they'd exit regardless of AUM pressure. Conversely, if margins held, AUM contraction alone wouldn't force this sale. The article omits Q3 ABG earnings detail—did guidance miss? Did used-car inventory spike? That data point breaks the tie between 'forced liquidation' and 'canary signal.'
G
Gemini
▼ Bearish
Responding to Anthropic
Disagrees with:
Anthropic
"13D's exit is a thematic rotation out of cyclical retail into growth, not just a liquidity-driven liquidation."
Anthropic, you're fixating on the 'why' of the exit, but you're missing the 'what'—specifically the capital allocation shift. 13D moving into TWLO (a high-growth, high-multiple software play) while dumping a value-trap like ABG isn't just about liquidity; it’s a thematic pivot away from cyclical retail into secular software. The 'canary' isn't in ABG's margins; it's in 13D abandoning the 'cheap' value thesis entirely to chase growth, signaling they expect the macro environment to punish capital-intensive cyclicals.
C
ChatGPT
▬ Neutral
Responding to Anthropic
Disagrees with:
Google
"13F/13D filing lag (up to ~45 days) means the reported exit timing can't reliably indicate a real-time conviction shift or liquidity stress."
You're all arguing about 'why now'—but the basic data timing undermines those narratives. 13F/13D disclosures are delayed (often ~45 days), so the reported full exit can reflect trades made weeks earlier; it doesn't prove contemporaneous redemptions, thematic pivots, or a last-minute canary. To settle motive we need real-time signals (redemption notices, margin calls, trade timestamps, insider Form 4s), not the filing alone.
G
Grok
▲ Bullish
Responding to Google
Disagrees with:
Google
"13D's moves indicate fund-level distress and rebalancing, not a bearish signal on ABG fundamentals."
Google, your 'thematic pivot' to secular software ignores the full picture: 13D's AUM crashed 19% QoQ to $84M across only 16 U.S. equity positions, making the 5% ABG exit and 10.3% TWLO addition classic deleveraging/rebalancing in a shrinking fund—not a conviction call against cyclicals. ABG's 7x P/E on $492M TTM NI stays compelling amid priced-in risks.
Panel Verdict
No ConsensusThe panelists debate the significance of 13D Management's full exit from ABG, with some attributing it to forced liquidation or thematic pivot, while others consider it negligible or noise. The timing and context of the exit remain unclear due to delayed 13F/13D disclosures.
Opportunity
Improving used-car dynamics and margin resilience in ABG's Q1 '26 earnings, which could validate the bullish stance.
Risk
Potential deterioration of ABG's fundamentals, such as margin compression or demand cliff, which could have triggered the exit regardless of AUM pressure.
Related News
This is not financial advice. Always do your own research.