Car insurance rose faster than groceries, gas, and rent combined

There’s a good chance your car insurance just got more expensive and it has nothing to do with your driving record. Since 2020, the cost of insuring your vehicle has surged roughly 55%, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
In that same window, groceries climbed about 25%, rent rose around 22%, and gasoline ended up roughly 15% higher. Even when all three are combined, they still fall short of the costs of car insurance alone.
This isn't just general inflation at work; repairs cost more, there aren't enough mechanics, injury payouts have nearly doubled, and massive jury verdicts are pushing insurers to charge more across the board. The rate of increase is slowing down, but premiums aren't coming back down anytime soon.
Here's what's behind it, who's paying the most, and what you can do about it.
Auto insurance has outpaced nearly every household expense since 2020
The Consumer Price Index for motor vehicle insurance rose 5.9% year-over-year as of February 2026, the BLS reports. That headline number is a sharp cooldown from the peak of roughly 20.6% annual growth recorded in early 2024,according to the Eno Center for Transportation.
“Now, even owning a car is unaffordable for many Nevadans. On top of skyrocketing gas prices and repair costs due to Trump’s war and tariffs, Nevadans have the highest full car insurance rates in the country,” Rep. Susie Lee, (D-NV) said in a statement.
Cumulatively, premiums are approximately 50% higher than they were in early 2020, based on BLS index data tracked by industry analysts. General inflation across all consumer goods and services totaled about 22% over that same window, less than half the insurance surge.
5 forces driving your premiums through the roof
Your car is more expensive to fix than it was five years ago, and that is the single biggest reason your premium keeps climbing.
1. Modern vehicles cost more to repair
The average new car now sells for roughly $47,740, and even mainstream brands have seen prices jump 27% since the end of 2019, according to Edmunds. A minor parking-lot scrape on a 2024 model with backup cameras and parking sensors can easily cost $3,000 to $5,000 in repairs and recalibration.
That same fender bender on a 2015 model without advanced safety technology might have cost only $400 to $800 at a standard body shop. Specialized diagnostic equipment, software updates, and sensor recalibration now drive repair bills far beyond what simple bodywork used to cost for older vehicles.
More Automotive:
-
Hyundai admits deadly defect caused more injuries than previously known
-
Consumer Reports names 5 popular EVs with the best real-world range
Your windshield alone now contains rain sensors, lane-departure cameras, and heads-up display projectors that can push a single glass replacement past $1,500. Even routine bumper replacements require technicians to reconnect and recalibrate parking sensors, blind-spot monitors, and automatic braking systems before returning your car to you.
These technology-driven repair costs hit your insurer's claims budget directly, and you absorb that expense through higher premiums, whether you personally file a claim or not.
2. There are not enough qualified mechanics to do the work
Ford CEO Jim Farley recently said the automaker is struggling to fill 5,000 mechanic positions that pay nearly double the median U.S. salary. That shortage drives up the labor portion of every repair bill, and those higher costs flow directly into the premiums you pay.
3. Used car values remain elevated
When a totaled vehicle is worth more, insurers must write bigger checks to replace it, and they recover that cost from you. The Manheim Used Vehicle Value Index spiked in 2021 and has remained elevated since, keeping total-loss payouts abnormally high for insurers.
4. Bodily injury claims are pushing payouts to record levels
The average payout for a bodily injury claim has climbed to about $29,100 per injured person, CCC Intelligent Solutions reports.
In 2016, that same average was roughly $16,082, meaning the typical bodily injury claim has grown nearly 81% in less than a decade. Rising healthcare costs are a primary driver, because emergency room visits, diagnostic imaging, and surgery all cost significantly more today.
5. Aggressive litigation is amplifying the financial damage
So-called "nuclear verdicts," or jury awards exceeding $10 million, have increased more than 50% in a single year, Marathon Strategies research shows.
The median among the top 50 U.S. bodily injury verdicts roughly doubled between 2019 and 2024, rising from $49.7 million to $98.2 million. Every inflated verdict raises the baseline for what insurers expect to pay, and those expectations get baked directly into your next renewal quote.
Some drivers are getting hit harder than others
Your ZIP code is a major factor in how insurers assess your risk, but it is far from the only variable working against you right now.
Low-income drivers face the steepest burden
Low-income drivers "have the least options to cut costs without sacrificing important coverage" when premiums rise, Jeffrey Nadrich, founder of Nadrich Accident Injury Lawyers, explained. For someone earning the median household income of $74,580, the average annual full-coverage premium of $2,678 now consumes 3.6% of gross pay.
Urban and high-risk-weather state drivers pay a premium on top of a premium
City drivers face higher base rates due to elevated rates of theft, vandalism, and accidents tied to congested roads and dense parking areas. Drivers in California, Florida, Texas, and Louisiana are seeing additional surcharges as insurers reassess their exposure to extreme weather across these states.
Electric vehicle owners are absorbing outsized increases
EV insurance jumped 28% in 2024, nearly double the rate for gas-powered vehicles, because EV repairs require specialized technicians and expensive parts. Even affordable EVs like the Nissan Leaf or Chevy Bolt carry premium penalties because repair networks remain limited and training is specialized.
How insurers are responding beyond just raising your rates
"Insurers know rate increases alone aren’t sustainable," Jeremy Jawish, CEO of insurance tech company Shift Technology, explained to Yahoo Finance.
Key industry shifts you should know about
-
Insurers are investing heavily in AI-powered fraud detection and automated claims processing to reduce operational costs on every single policy.
-
Tighter underwriting practices now use telematics data and credit scoring to more precisely price individual risk profiles for each policyholder.
-
Some major insurers have exited high-risk states entirely when local regulators cap the rate increases they may charge consumers.
-
Usage-based insurance programs reward safe drivers with lower premiums by tracking driving behavior through a smartphone app or plug-in device.
These shifts mean your next policy renewal might look very different from the last one, even if you stay with the exact same company.
Seven moves to lower your car insurance bill
You cannot control inflation or the cost of auto parts, but you do have real leverage over what you personally pay each month going forward.
Steps you can take before your next renewal
-
Comparison shop at every renewal: Gather at least 3 quotes before accepting your current carrier’s renewal offer, because loyalty very rarely earns lower rates.
-
Raise your deductible strategically: Increasing your comprehensive and collision deductible from $500 to $1,000 can reduce your premium, but only if you have cash reserves to cover the higher deductible.
-
Bundle your policies: Buying auto and homeowners or renters insurance from the same provider can save you 10% or more on both of your policies.
-
Ask about every available discount: Safe driver, low mileage, paperless billing, and professional association discounts can add up to meaningful savings that most people never claim.
-
Try usage-based insurance if you drive safely: Telematics programs track your braking, speed, and mileage, and they can offset other risk factors that would otherwise raise your premium.
-
Drop collision and comprehensive on older vehicles: If your car’s market value is less than ten times your annual premium for those coverages, the math stops working in your favor.
-
Improve your credit score: Most states allow insurers to factor your credit report into pricing, so raising your score from fair to good could save hundreds annually.
The 2026 outlook suggests slower increases but not real relief
Multiple industry experts project moderate, low-single-digit premium increases for 2026, a notable cooldown from the double-digit spikes of 2023 and 2024. Craig Martin of J.D. Power’s Global Insurance Intelligence team expects "stable or potentially moderate auto premium increases" for the rest of this year.
Jae E. Lee, founder of Jay Lee Law, anticipates statewide premium increases between 1% and 4%, with tariffs on auto parts posing an upside risk. "Insurers are still underwriting losses for previous years, which means rate increases are likely to continue or hold flat at best," Zander Cook, CRO at Lease End, noted.
The bottom line for you is straightforward: premiums are unlikely to drop in 2026, but the pace of increases should feel less painful than recent years. Your best defense remains proactive shopping, strategic coverage adjustments, and a clean driving record heading into every single renewal cycle you face.
Related: Reasons Why Your Car Insurance May Be Rising Fast
This story was originally published by TheStreet on Apr 3, 2026, where it first appeared in the Automotive section. Add TheStreet as a Preferred Source by clicking here.