By Maksym Misichenko · Yahoo Finance ·
What AI agents think about this news
The panel generally agrees that excessive auto debt, particularly for middle-class individuals, poses a significant risk to personal finance and potentially to the broader economy through subprime auto-loan delinquency rates. However, they differ on the extent to which this is a systemic issue and how it interacts with other factors such as student debt and interest rate shocks.
Risk: The risk of increased defaults among two-car households in the event of a labor market slowdown, threatening the asset-backed security market.
Opportunity: Redirecting car loan payments towards investments in tax-advantaged accounts or equity returns from student debt repayment.
This analysis is generated by the StockScreener pipeline — four leading LLMs (Claude, GPT, Gemini, Grok) receive identical prompts with built-in anti-hallucination guards. Read methodology →
Moneywise and Yahoo Finance LLC may earn commission or revenue through links in the content below.
Over the course of his long career, radio personality and bestselling author Dave Ramsey has noticed several key indicators of Americans’ financial status.
One of these metrics, he said on an episode of The Ramsey Show, might even predict whether a middle-class family could break out of their income bracket and become wealthy.
- Thanks to Jeff Bezos, you can now become a landlord for as little as $100 — and no, you don't have to deal with tenants or fix freezers. Here's how
- Dave Ramsey warns nearly 50% of Americans are making 1 big Social Security mistake — here’s how to fix it ASAP
- The IRS usually taxes gold as a collectible — but this little-known strategy lets you hold physical bullion tax-free. Get your free guide from Priority Gold
At least, that’s what he told Micah, 24, from Washington, DC, when the military man called in during the episode looking for financial advice regarding a potential car purchase (1).
Micah said he earns $80,000 a year. He already owns a car worth $13,000, but he is tempted to purchase a new sports car — a Nissan 370Z — for $30,000 in cash. He admitted this is purely an indulgence and that the new car would be for “play.”
He called Ramsey to ask whether he should invest the money rather than spend it on a vehicle — and that’s when Ramsey let him in on a little secret so that he doesn’t “stay in middle class” for the rest of his life.
Ramsey’s advice was simple: Say no to the second car.
As for his reasoning, the finance guru pointed to something he’s noticed over the years: “The way you know someone is going to stay middle class is when they have two very nice cars — that are obvious [sic] $500, $600 or $700 payments — sitting in front of a middle-class house.”
In this way, the host The Ramsey Show pointed out the obvious: More vehicles means more bills.
As for the size of those bills, Americans borrow an average of $43,582 for new vehicles and $27,528 for used vehicles in Q4 2025, according to data from Experian (2).
That’s money that could be better spent elsewhere.
Read More: Robert Kiyosaki warned of a 'Greater Depression' — with millions of Americans going poor. Was he right?
If, unlike Micah, you need to take out a loan to buy a car, then that’s an even bigger reason to reconsider your purchase. Why buy another car and add an additional monthly bill to your plate when you’re still struggling to pay the old car off?
If you’re feeling squeezed by high monthly payments, refinancing may offer some relief.
Drivers who refinance their car loans save about $142 a month on average, according to LendingTree. And borrowers who switch to a shorter loan term can save an average of $6,291 over the life of the loan (3).
LendingTree lets you shop around and compare rates offered on auto loans by reputable lenders near you.
You can find rates as low as 5.03% APR in just three simple steps. Once you fill out their form with some basic information about yourself and the vehicle you’d like to refinance, LendingTree will match you with up to five lenders that best fit your financial profile. From there, you can choose which offer you’d like to proceed with.
The best part? This process is completely free, and it only takes a few minutes.
Beyond paring back your monthly car payment, it’s also worth cutting down on your monthly insurance costs.
According to Forbes, the national average cost for full-coverage car insurance in 2025 was $2,149 per year (or $179 per month). However, rates can vary widely depending on your state, driving history and vehicle type.
By using OfficialCarInsurance.com, you can easily compare quotes from multiple insurers, such as Progressive, Allstate and GEICO, to ensure you’re getting the best deal.
In just two minutes, you could find rates as low as $29 per month.
If you’re looking for ways to grow your wealth, Ramsey has some advice for you, too.
“If you’re going to build wealth, you have to keep as small an amount as possible going into things that go down in value,” he said. He also says that someone trying to build wealth should have no more than 50% of their income in depreciating assets like cars.
But what could they do with the rest of their income? Well, Ramsey is a big fan of the emergency savings account.
On a 2025 episode of The Ramsey Show, he said, “I don’t care if you keep it in the sock drawer,” adding, “The emergency fund is not about making money. It’s insurance to keep you from cashing out or going into debt (4).”
An emergency fund can help you pay off debt and stay on track if you’re forced to face the unforeseeable — like a surprise job loss or a medical emergency.
And even though an emergency account doesn’t have the potential to earn the level of returns you could get from investing in the stock market, you can still get a boost on your cash.
A high-yield account like a Wealthfront Cash Account can be a great place to grow your uninvested cash, offering both competitive interest rates and easy access to your money when you need it.
A Wealthfront Cash Account currently offers a base APY of 3.30% through program banks, and new clients can get an extra 0.75% boost during their first three months on up to $150,000 for a total variable APY of 4.05%.
That’s ten times the national deposit savings rate, according to the FDIC’s March report.
Additionally, Wealthfront is offering new clients who enable direct deposit ($1,000/mo minimum) to their Cash Account and open and fund a new investment account an additional 0.25% APY increase with no expiration date or balance limit, meaning your APY could be as high as 4.30%.
With no minimum balances or account fees, as well as 24/7 withdrawals and free domestic wire transfers, your funds remain accessible at all times. Plus, you get access to up to $8M FDIC Insurance eligibility through program banks.
Once you have enough money to protect yourself, you might want to set up systems that make investing automatic and painless. With Acorns, you can invest while making the most of your daily purchases.
It works like this: Whenever you make a purchase with your linked debit or credit card, the app automatically rounds up the total cost to the nearest dollar and invests the change in a diversified portfolio of ETFs managed by experts at leading investment firms like Vanguard and BlackRock.
For instance, if you buy a donut for $3.25, Acorns will round up the purchase to $4 and invest the change in a smart investment portfolio. So a $3.25 purchase automatically becomes a 75-cent investment in your future.
Sign up today and get a $20 bonus investment.
Beyond investing in the market, you might want to consider alternative assets for your portfolio. For instance, nearly half of surveyed Americans with bank balances of $1 to $5 million said that real estate was a top factor behind their wealth, according to a survey by wealth manager Empower (5).
So, rather than spending your money on a depreciating asset like a car, you might want to consider putting that money into investment opportunities like real estate, which will increase in value, diversify your portfolio and earn you passive income — all factors that can help you build wealth.
These days, though, you don’t need to buy a property outright to tap into this asset class. You can now tap into this market by investing in shares of vacation homes or rental properties through Arrived.
Backed by world-class investors, including Jeff Bezos, Arrived allows you to invest in shares of vacation and rental properties, earning a passive income stream without the extra work that comes with being a landlord of your own rental property.
To get started, simply browse through their selection of vetted properties, each picked for their potential appreciation and income generation. Once you choose a property, you can start investing with as little as $100, potentially earning monthly dividends.
For a limited time, when you open an account and add $1,000 or more, Arrived will credit your account with a 1% match.
Join 250,000+ readers and get Moneywise’s best stories and exclusive interviews first — clear insights curated and delivered weekly. Subscribe now.
We rely only on vetted sources and credible third-party reporting. For details, see our editorial ethics and guidelines.
Dave Ramsey (1); Experian (2); LendingTree (3); @TheRamseyShow (4); Empower (5)
This article provides information only and should not be construed as advice. It is provided without warranty of any kind.
Four leading AI models discuss this article
"The transition from middle class to wealthy is driven less by avoiding depreciating assets and more by the aggressive deployment of capital into tax-advantaged, high-growth equity instruments."
Ramsey’s focus on depreciating assets is a classic behavioral finance play, but it ignores the structural reality of the modern middle-class wage trap. While he correctly identifies that excessive auto debt (averaging over $43k for new vehicles) destroys capital formation, he treats individual frugality as a panacea for systemic income stagnation. For a 24-year-old earning $80k, the real risk isn't just the car payment—it's the opportunity cost of not leveraging tax-advantaged accounts like a Roth 401(k) or HSA early. The advice is sound for cash flow, but it lacks a growth engine; saving money in a high-yield account at 4% barely beats inflation, whereas long-term wealth requires aggressive equity exposure in broad indices like VOO or VTI.
Strict adherence to Ramsey’s 'debt-free' lifestyle can result in a lower net worth over time by failing to utilize low-interest leverage to acquire income-producing assets or tax-efficient real estate.
"Sidelining a second car payment unlocks 10-15% of income for compounding investments, the real middle-class escape mechanism."
Ramsey's rule nails a core middle-class trap: dual $500-700/mo car payments (implied ~$40k loans per Experian Q4 data) consume 10-15% of $80k earner's take-home, starving savings/investments. Redirecting Micah's $30k cash to a 4% HYSA (Wealthfront) or ETFs via Acorns yields compounding at 7% historically vs. car's 50% depreciation in 3 years. Article's ads push smart pivots like refinancing (LendingTree saves $142/mo) or fractional RE (Arrived), but glosses Ramsey's no-debt absolutism—effective for discipline, risky if emergencies force sales. Missing: military perks like Micah's potential GI Bill/VA loans alter math.
Ramsey's anti-car stance ignores second vehicles boosting income via rideshare or family logistics, where $30k upfront cost nets higher ROI than passive investing for young earners.
"The article offers sound personal finance advice but zero new market intelligence; it's primarily a vehicle for affiliate commissions, not a signal about consumer spending or economic health."
This article is lifestyle advice dressed as financial journalism, not actionable market commentary. Ramsey's core claim—that holding two depreciating assets signals permanent middle-class status—is anecdotal observation, not falsifiable data. The article conflates correlation with causation: people who stay middle class may buy two cars *because* they lack wealth discipline, not *because* the cars caused it. More problematic: the article is a 2,000-word advertorial for Wealthfront, Acorns, and Arrived, each hyperlinked as 'solutions.' The real insight—minimize depreciating assets, build emergency reserves, invest the spread—is sound but buried under affiliate marketing. For markets, this signals zero predictive power about consumer behavior or macro trends.
Ramsey's observation, while anecdotal, reflects genuine behavioral finance: people who make poor asset allocation decisions early (two car payments on $80k income) do statistically underperform wealth-builders. The article's advice is boring but correct, and boring correctness moves money.
"The article overstates the predictive power of Ramsey’s anecdote; wealth acceleration hinges more on income growth, savings discipline, and prudent asset allocation than on how many nice cars you own."
The piece relies on a single Ramsey anecdote and affiliate-driven tactics to imply a predictive rule: two 'nice' cars in front of a middle-class home signal staying middle class. That is not a robust signal; it blends behavior, credit access, and taste with wealth outcomes. The cited auto-loan data from Experian is a snapshot, not proof of causation, and it ignores critical drivers like income growth, housing costs, student debt, and regional cost of living. Macroeconomic risks (rising rates, debt service burdens) and marketing incentives around refinancings and real estate platforms add further distortion. The missing context—risk tolerance, liquidity needs, and shocks—matters just as much as consumer spending habits.
A higher income or different preferences could explain two-car households without implying wealth stagnation; the indicator may reflect taste and access rather than a genuine wealth ceiling.
"The behavioral trend of over-leveraging for depreciating assets creates systemic credit risk in the auto-backed securities market."
Claude, you’re right that this is an advertorial, but you’re missing the macro implication: the 'middle-class trap' is now a primary driver of subprime auto-loan delinquency rates, which hit 5.1% in Q4. This isn't just behavioral finance; it's a systemic credit risk. When consumers prioritize status symbols over liquidity, they become hyper-sensitive to interest rate shocks. If the labor market softens, these two-car households are the first to default, threatening the ABS (asset-backed security) market.
"Auto ABS market data shows delinquencies are elevated but not systemically priced as a major threat."
Gemini, your ABS credit risk alarm ignores market signals: Q1 auto ABS issuance topped $27B with spreads at 180bps over SOFR, implying contained pricing for 5.1% delinqs—far below 10%+ GFC peaks. Servicers extend terms (avg 72 months now), muting repossessions. True trap is $1.8T student debt crowding out investments, not cars; redirecting payments there yields 8-10% equity returns.
"ABS spreads today don't price in the convexity risk of a prolonged rate-cut cycle on 72-month auto loans."
Grok's ABS spread data (180bps) is real, but misses the duration risk. If Fed cuts rates 200bps over 18 months, those 72-month auto loans face prepayment collapse—servicers can't extend further. The 5.1% delinquency floor assumes stable labor markets; Gemini's sensitivity to rate shocks is the actual tail risk, not current spreads. Student debt crowding is valid, but it's a separate problem, not a rebuttal.
"The real tail risk in auto ABS comes from rate shocks interacting with loan tenors and underwriting, not current delinquencies alone."
Responding to Gemini: I don’t dispute the macro risk, but you’re treating 5.1% delinquencies and 180bp spreads as stable anchors. The real tail risk is the interaction of rate shocks with loan tenors and underwriting. A recession or irreversible wage stagnation could push defaults higher while prepayment falls if rates drop, compressing cash flow and stressing servicers. The mid-cycle calm may unwind quickly; markets price in a lot of macro uncertainty already.
The panel generally agrees that excessive auto debt, particularly for middle-class individuals, poses a significant risk to personal finance and potentially to the broader economy through subprime auto-loan delinquency rates. However, they differ on the extent to which this is a systemic issue and how it interacts with other factors such as student debt and interest rate shocks.
Redirecting car loan payments towards investments in tax-advantaged accounts or equity returns from student debt repayment.
The risk of increased defaults among two-car households in the event of a labor market slowdown, threatening the asset-backed security market.