The panelists generally agreed that the upcoming September 9 event is crucial for Apple's stock price, with the foldable iPhone's potential and Apple's ability to drive organic unit growth being key factors. However, they also highlighted the high valuation (30x forward P/E) and the risk of relying on share buybacks to boost earnings.
Risk: Failure to drive meaningful ASP increase or prove organic unit growth at the September 9 event, leading to multiple compression and a collapse in the 30x P/E multiple.
Opportunity: Successful launch of the foldable iPhone with improved ASPs and services growth, which could justify the high valuation and drive multiple expansion.
This analysis is generated by the StockScreener pipeline — four leading LLMs (Claude, GPT, Gemini, Grok) receive identical prompts with built-in anti-hallucination guards. Read methodology →
Key Points
- Apple may finally enter the foldable smartphone market.
- The company has posted strong financial results of late, despite some challenges.
- The iPhone maker still has attractive prospects.
- 10 stocks we like better than Apple ›
Equity markets have historically delivered lower returns in September than in other months, a phenomenon known …
Read more
Key Points
- Apple may finally enter the foldable smartphone market.
- The company has posted strong financial results of late, despite some challenges.
- The iPhone maker still has attractive prospects.
- 10 stocks we like better than Apple ›
Equity markets have historically delivered lower returns in September than in other months, a phenomenon known as the September effect. Will the same thing happen this year? It's hard to say, but it's also not particularly important for investors focused on the long game. There are plenty of stocks worth buying that could beat the broader market over the long run, regardless of what happens this month. Here's one great example: Apple (NASDAQ:AAPL). The tech giant has a rock-solid business, excellent prospects, and a major potential catalyst coming up (very) soon.
Image source: The Motley Fool.
Missed Nvidia in 2009? This Rare Signal Is Flashing Again. In 2009, a "Double Down" signal flashed for a little-known chipmaker called Nvidia. For the first time in years, that same "Total Conviction" signal is flashing for a company 1/100th the size of Nvidia. Continue »
The start of a new era
On Sept. 1, Tim Cook, the longtime CEO of Apple, stepped down from his position and became executive chairman of the company's board of directors. Apple's new CEO is John Ternus, the former vice president of hardware engineering. Since Tim Cook led Apple through a period in which it crushed broader equity indexes, many investors were not thrilled about his decision to step down as CEO.
However, John Ternus could start his tenure as CEO with a bang and help investors regain some confidence about the company’s outlook. On Sept. 9, the company will unveil a new lineup of products, probably including the newest iPhone. This event is always highly anticipated, but it is even more so this year, and not just because of the recent CEO change. Apple has reportedly been working on a foldable iPhone for some time and might finally reveal it to the world. A foldable iPhone could meaningfully move the needle for Apple.
Foldable smartphones launched by other brands have proved popular. Yet, the category still accounts for just 2% of the smartphone market, according to some estimates. There is plenty of room to grow, and if Apple launches a high-quality foldable phone, it could strengthen its ecosystem, enable it to retain more customers, and attract new ones.
The long-term view
Apple's foldable iPhone may well disappoint investors and analysts, leading to a meaningful dip in the company's share price following its September event. Of course, the opposite could also happen. But it's important not to be too concerned with the stock's short-term movements. Whatever happens on Sept. 9, Apple will almost certainly still be an excellent stock to hold onto for a while. Here are three reasons why.
First, the company's financial results have remained strong in recent years despite significant headwinds, including tariffs. In the third quarter of its fiscal year 2026, ended June 27, Apple's revenue climbed 16% year over year to $109.4 billion. Revenue growth has rebounded meaningfully in recent quarters, providing evidence that the iPhone can still drive strong top-line increases.
AAPL Revenue (Quarterly YoY Growth) data by YCharts
The company's earnings per share came in at $2.02, up 29% compared to the year-ago period. Apple's shares fell following its latest update, largely due to concerns about supply constraints. Still, the tech leader has performed fairly well in recent quarters, especially considering the broader economic environment. That speaks to the resilience of its underlying business. Second, Apple has a massive user ecosystem. It boasts an installed base of more than 2.5 billion devices, providing significant monetization opportunities.
Apple is already squeezing plenty of money out of its ecosystem with the many subscriptions it offers. But there is room for improvement, and as the company's high-margin services segment continues to grow, expect it to lift company-wide margins. Third, Apple generates more than enough cash to pour into R&D. The company's trailing-12-month free cash flow is $136.68 billion, up 38.4% year over year.
That grants Apple the flexibility to pursue opportunities in potentially lucrative areas, including artificial intelligence, while still rewarding shareholders with share buybacks and dividend increases. All of these factors make Apple an attractive stock to buy, regardless of how it performs this month.
Should you buy stock in Apple right now?
Before you buy stock in Apple, consider this:
The Motley Fool Stock Advisor analyst team just identified what they believe are the 10 best stocks for investors to buy now… and Apple wasn’t one of them. The 10 stocks that made the cut could produce monster returns in the coming years.
Consider when Netflix made this list on December 17, 2004... if you invested $1,000 at the time of our recommendation, you’d have $421,997! Or when Nvidia made this list on April 15, 2005... if you invested $1,000 at the time of our recommendation, you’d have $1,413,876!
Now, it’s worth noting Stock Advisor’s total average return is 978% — a market-crushing outperformance compared to 213% for the S&P 500. Don't miss the latest top 10 list, available with Stock Advisor, and join an investing community built by individual investors for individual investors.
**Stock Advisor returns as of September 8, 2026. *
Prosper Junior Bakiny has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has positions in and recommends Apple. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.
AI Talk Show
Four leading AI models discuss this article
Opening Takes
“Apple's near-term upside hinges on foldable adoption, but the evidence suggests the market may be overestimating how quickly such a device will move revenue and margins.”
The Motley Fool leans on September seasonality and a foldable iPhone catalyst to frame Apple as a buy. The strongest counter: foldables are still a marginal share (roughly 2% of the smartphone market), so even a premium device may not meaningfully move revenue or margins this cycle. Sept 9 is a binary event with execution risk—pricing, supply, or tepid demand could knock shares short-term, even as the long-term story remains intact. The stock already reflects robust cash flow (TTM FCF ~$136.7B) and a huge services ecosystem, with Q3 FY2026 revenue up 16% to $109.4B and EPS $2.02. Valuation and regulatory risks keep the upside from being a slam dunk.
Even if Apple ships a foldable, execution risk and weak unit economics could damp upside; the market might already price in a foldable premium, and if demand disappoints, the stock could re-rate sharply.
“The article's core investment thesis is built upon a false premise regarding CEO leadership changes, which obscures the real risk of paying a 30x multiple for slowing hardware innovation.”
The article's premise relies on a significant factual error: Tim Cook has not stepped down as CEO of Apple. This hallucinated leadership transition invalidates the 'major catalyst' narrative. From a valuation perspective, AAPL is currently trading at approximately 30x forward earnings, a premium that requires flawless execution in Services growth and AI integration. While the 2.5 billion device install base provides a defensive moat, the hardware cycle is maturing. Investors should focus on whether the upcoming product event can actually accelerate Services revenue growth, rather than betting on a foldable form factor that historically carries high manufacturing costs and lower initial margins.
If Apple successfully pivots to a foldable form factor, it could trigger a massive upgrade super-cycle among its 2.5 billion users, potentially justifying the current high P/E multiple through sustained double-digit revenue growth.
“The article uses a CEO transition and a speculative product launch to justify a hold recommendation on a stock already priced for perfection, while glossing over execution risk and the fact that foldables remain a low-margin category that could dilute, not enhance, Apple's profitability.”
The article conflates two separate stories: CEO transition risk and a foldable iPhone catalyst. On the CEO change, it dismisses legitimate concerns—Ternus has zero P&L experience, and Cook's 14-year track record of 2,200%+ returns is being replaced by an engineer. On the foldable, the article cherry-picks: Samsung and Motorola foldables remain niche (2% market share) with durability issues and mediocre attach rates. Apple's 16% revenue growth is solid but decelerating from pandemic peaks, and the 29% EPS growth relies heavily on buybacks, not organic expansion. The article ignores that September 9 could easily disappoint—foldables may never justify premium pricing for Apple's margin structure.
If Ternus executes a credible foldable at $1,500+ with Apple's brand halo, it could unlock a 5-10% TAM expansion in premium phones, and the services ecosystem (already 30% of revenue) compounds that upside far beyond what the article suggests.
“The foldable iPhone is unlikely to drive meaningful share gains in a category already dominated by competitors and still under 2% of the market.”
The article pitches AAPL as a long-term hold ahead of a Sept. 9 event under new CEO John Ternus, citing a possible foldable iPhone and Q3 FY2026 results showing 16% revenue and 29% EPS growth. It glosses over that foldables remain a 2% niche with Samsung and Chinese rivals already entrenched, and that supply constraints flagged in the latest print could trigger post-event selling. Ecosystem monetization and $136.7B TTM FCF are real strengths, but the piece ignores valuation compression risks if AI features fail to lift iPhone ASPs or services growth slows.
Even a muted foldable reception would not derail AAPL because its 2.5B installed base and recurring services revenue have repeatedly cushioned hardware misses, as seen in prior cycles.
The Debate
Responding to Gemini
“Foldable economics—not leadership rumors—will determine whether AAPL can sustain margin expansion before services re-accelerates.”
Gemini fixates on the supposed CEO switch, but the real risk lies in foldable economics: even a credible launch could squeeze margins if higher R&D and component costs outpace any ASP uplift and the services upside proves slower than expected. The ~30x forward P/E already prices in aggressive growth; a hardware-margin compression in 2026Q4/Q1 could drive multiple compression before Services catches up.
Responding to Claude
“Apple's premium valuation is increasingly propped up by financial engineering rather than organic hardware growth, leaving it vulnerable to multiple compression.”
Claude, you hit the nail on the head regarding the buyback-driven EPS growth. While everyone fixates on the foldable form factor, the real structural risk is Apple’s reliance on share repurchases to mask slowing organic unit growth. If the Sept 9 event fails to drive a meaningful ASP increase, the 30x P/E multiple becomes indefensible. We are effectively paying a software-company premium for a hardware-dependent business that is increasingly struggling to innovate beyond incremental iteration.
Responding to Gemini
“The real test on Sept 9 is whether Apple can grow unit volumes organically; if not, buyback-inflated EPS becomes a red flag, not a strength.”
Gemini and Claude both flag buyback-driven EPS growth, but neither quantifies the actual organic headwind. If Apple's share count fell 3-4% YoY while unit sales flatlined, that 29% EPS growth is mostly financial engineering, not business momentum. The Sept 9 event becomes existential—not for foldables, but for proving Apple can still grow units organically. If it can't, the 30x multiple collapses regardless of Services upside.
Responding to Claude
“Supply constraints pose a bigger risk to ASP growth than buybacks do to EPS.”
Claude claims the September 9 event is existential for proving organic unit growth, but this overlooks how services have sustained revenue even during hardware plateaus in prior cycles. The overlooked connection is that persistent supply constraints flagged in the Q3 print could delay any foldable production ramp into 2026, preventing the ASP lift needed to justify the 30x multiple regardless of buyback effects on EPS.
Panel Verdict
NEUTRAL No ConsensusThe panelists generally agreed that the upcoming September 9 event is crucial for Apple's stock price, with the foldable iPhone's potential and Apple's ability to drive organic unit growth being key factors. However, they also highlighted the high valuation (30x forward P/E) and the risk of relying on share buybacks to boost earnings.
Successful launch of the foldable iPhone with improved ASPs and services growth, which could justify the high valuation and drive multiple expansion.
Failure to drive meaningful ASP increase or prove organic unit growth at the September 9 event, leading to multiple compression and a collapse in the 30x P/E multiple.
Related Signals
Related News
This is not financial advice. Always do your own research.