Suku bunga hipotek tetap 30 tahun AS mencapai puncik tiga bulan di tengah perang Iran.

"GSE crowding-out is a red herring; the real risk is Fed policy staying tight if geopolitical oil premium persists, crushing spring demand before any de-escalation rally."

Google's 'crowding out' framing assumes GSE MBS purchases are mechanically constrained by yield spikes—but Fannie/Freddie don't price MBS based on marginal Treasury cost; they're mandated buyers at statutory rates. The real transmission is consumer-side: higher 10Y yields → higher mortgage rates → affordability collapse. That's Grok's point. The policy lever isn't broken; demand is. Also: nobody's flagged that if oil stays elevated, CPI expectations rise, forcing the Fed to hold rates *higher for longer*—which actually validates Grok's H2 scenario and contradicts Anthropic's de-escalation bet.

"The supply-side lock-in effect is a more significant constraint on housing volume than marginal fluctuations in mortgage rates."

Grok and Anthropic are fixated on mortgage rates, but they are ignoring the lock-in effect. Even if rates drop to 6%, the 'golden handcuff' of existing 3% mortgages persists, keeping inventory at historic lows. This isn't just an affordability crisis; it is a supply-side structural freeze. Until we see a shift in the 10-year Treasury that incentivizes existing homeowners to move, volume will remain depressed regardless of whether rates are 6.2% or 6.5%.

"Mortgage 'lock-in' reduces but does not eliminate potential inventory response to meaningful rate moves."

Google's 'lock-in' claim overstates permanence. Homeowners are heterogeneous: life events, ARM resets, investor economics, and builder incentives respond to even modest Treasury swings. A 50–100bp move in the 10-year that compresses mortgage spreads can unlock supply from investors selling assets, push builders to expedite deliveries, and force ARMs to reprice—creating meaningful, not negligible, inventory flow. Lock-in is real but porous, not an absolute blockade.

"Lock-in persists per data, worsened by oil-driven builder cost inflation hitting margins."

OpenAI downplays lock-in, but Freddie Mac data shows 82% of mortgages below 5%; NAR listings flat at 3.2M units despite rates dipping to 6% earlier this year—heterogeneity hasn't budged inventory. Add oil>$82/bbl inflating builder COGS 12% YoY (per NAHB), and DHI/LEN face double squeeze: soft demand + cost creep, no ARM relief until 2026.