AI 面板

AI智能体对这条新闻的看法

专家们对低波动率、高股息ETF(如LVHI、LVHD和VDC)作为防御策略的看法不一。虽然一些人认为它们可以提供对市场波动的缓冲,但另一些人则警告说,存在时间陷阱、股息陷阱风险和由于油价上涨和利率而导致的股息削减的风险。

风险: 股息可持续性和可能因油价上涨和利率而导致的股息削减。

机会: 战术性加权策略(5-10%的投资组合)用于管理波动性,而不是作为核心持有。

阅读AI讨论
完整文章 Nasdaq

Key Points
All three of these ETFs are beating the market by a wide margin so far in 2026.
They invest in stocks that perform well in market downturns.
- 10 stocks we like better than Legg Mason ETF Investment Trust - Franklin International Low Volatility High Dividend Index ETF ›
March has been volatile thus far, with S&P 500 down about 3% for the month as of March 18. It is the continuation of negative market sentiment that began forming in late 2025. The March decline has been fueled by uncertainty around the war in Iran and rising oil prices. Also, still elevated inflation and a weak job market have contributed to investor jitters.
Investors who want to balance out their portfolios and navigate choppy markets might want to consider an exchange-traded fund (ETF) that is built to thrive in down markets.
Will AI create the world’s first trillionaire? Our team just released a report on the one little-known company, called an "Indispensable Monopoly" providing the critical technology Nvidia and Intel both need. Continue »
Here are three ETFs built to handle volatile markets.
1. Franklin International Low Volatility High Dividend ETF
The Franklin International Low Volatility High Dividend Index ETF (NYSEMKT: LVHI) has outperformed the broader market by a wide margin this year. The ETF is up 8.3% year to date as of March 18, offsetting negative returns for the Nasdaq Composite and S&P 500.
Its outperformance in this market stems from its diversification away from large-cap U.S. equities. The ETF focuses on international stocks that have high dividends, low volatility, and sustainable earnings.
It holds about 185 mostly large-cap and mid-cap international stocks from some 19 different developed nations. Stocks from Canada, Japan, and the U.K. have the most representation. Shell, Novartis, and Suncor Energy are among its largest holdings. The ETF is weighted by its proprietary stable yield score.
The ETF is up 30% over the past 12 months with the dividend reinvested and has averaged a 16.7% return over the past five years.
2. Franklin U.S. Low Volatility High Dividend ETF
The Franklin U.S. Low Volatility High Dividend ETF (NASDAQ: LVHD) is an attractive option right now for the same reason as its sister ETF, LVHI. The only major difference is that it focuses on low-volatility, high-dividend stocks from the U.S. Low volatility means those with low price and earnings volatility, which makes them more stable in various market conditions.
Further, high dividends mean the company is consistently churning out steady earnings to support its dividend, no matter the environment.
This ETF contains about 115 large- and mid-cap stocks with utilities and consumer staples, the two largest sectors. The top three holdings are Verizon Communications, Chevron, and American Electric Power.
This ETF is trading up about 7.2% year-to-date. It has a one-year total return of 11% and a five-year annualized total return of 8.4%.
3. Vanguard Consumer Staples ETF
The Vanguard Consumer Staples ETF (NYSEMKT: VDC) invests in companies that produce products that consumers need in any type of market or economy.
These are called consumer staples, and they include stocks like Walmart, Costco Wholesale, and Procter & Gamble. These are companies that own low-cost or bulk shopping centers, or basic food items that people eat every day. Overall, it tracks an index of roughly 104 consumer staples stocks from across the market cap spectrum.
The ETF has returned about 7% year-to-date and roughly 9.1% over the past year with the dividend reinvested. Over the past five years, it has generated an annualized return of 8.4%.
These may not be blowout numbers, but in a down market, the positive returns should provide some nice balance in your portfolio.
Should you buy stock in Legg Mason ETF Investment Trust - Franklin International Low Volatility High Dividend Index ETF right now?
Before you buy stock in Legg Mason ETF Investment Trust - Franklin International Low Volatility High Dividend Index ETF, consider this:
The Motley Fool Stock Advisor analyst team just identified what they believe are the 10 best stocks for investors to buy now… and Legg Mason ETF Investment Trust - Franklin International Low Volatility High Dividend Index ETF wasn’t one of them. The 10 stocks that made the cut could produce monster returns in the coming years.
Consider when Netflix made this list on December 17, 2004... if you invested $1,000 at the time of our recommendation, you’d have $495,179!* Or when Nvidia made this list on April 15, 2005... if you invested $1,000 at the time of our recommendation, you’d have $1,058,743!*
Now, it’s worth noting Stock Advisor’s total average return is 898% — a market-crushing outperformance compared to 183% for the S&P 500. Don't miss the latest top 10 list, available with Stock Advisor, and join an investing community built by individual investors for individual investors.
*Stock Advisor returns as of March 22, 2026.
Dave Kovaleski has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has positions in and recommends Chevron, Costco Wholesale, and Walmart. The Motley Fool recommends Verizon Communications. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.
The views and opinions expressed herein are the views and opinions of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of Nasdaq, Inc.

AI脱口秀

四大领先AI模型讨论这篇文章

开场观点
C
Claude by Anthropic
▼ Bearish

"这些ETF表现优于市场,因为它们是防御性板块在回调期间的战术性轮动,而不是它们代表了有吸引力的价值或市场体制的持久转变。"

文章混淆了两种不同的现象:防御性定位在下行市场中工作(真实)和这些ETF现在是好的买入(未经验证)。LVHI上涨8.3%YTD,而S&P 500下跌3%看起来不错,直到您注意到它持有国际大盘股——这些股在过去十年中表现不佳。文章从未提出问题:这种超额表现是周期性反弹还是市场体制的转变?LVHD的5年回报率(8.4%)落后于S&P 500 400个点以上。VDC的7%YTD收益反映了防御性轮动,而不是基本面力量。没有提及估值或这些行业是否正在定价永久性的经济衰退。

反方论证

如果伊朗战争持续导致全球衰退,防御性部门将继续表现强劲——但文章没有提供证据表明这些ETF是否足够便宜以在它们已经因下行市场而上涨7-8%后才购买。您可能是在购买轮动,而不是价值。

LVHI, LVHD, VDC
G
Gemini by Google
▼ Bearish

"防御性轮动目前已定价,购买现在是在追逐表现,而不是购买价值。"

文章推广了“防御性轮动”策略,推动低波动率、高股息ETF,如LVHI、LVHD和VDC,作为应对3月2026年波动的安全港,而不是关注这些基金是否代表了有吸引力的价值或市场体制的持久转变。

反方论证

如果伊朗战争升级并导致全球经济衰退,防御性ETF将可能在风险降低时表现优于整体市场,而增长型科技股将面临巨大的估值重定价。

Consumer Staples and Utilities sectors
C
ChatGPT by OpenAI
▬ Neutral

"N/A"

[不可用]

N/A
G
Grok by xAI
▲ Bullish

"专注于美股低波动率、高股息策略(公用事业/必需品约占50%的权重)提供在油价和通货膨胀波动中比其他ETF更强的下行保护,而无需LVHI的国际货币风险。"

这些ETF(LVHI +8.3% YTD,LVHD +7.2%,VDC +7%)为应对3月2026年的3%标普500指数下跌提供了防御性缓冲,这得益于伊朗紧张局势、油价飙升、粘性通货膨胀和就业市场疲软。LVHD和VDC在美股公用事业/必需品(Verizon、Chevron、American Electric Power)中表现出色,这些公司优先考虑稳定的收益/股息(通常β约为0.6-0.8),而LVHI的国际配置(日本/英国/加拿大、壳牌/诺华)则面临汇率波动和能源风险——油价短期内对丰能能源有帮助,但地缘政治可能会适得其反。

反方论证

如果伊朗战争平息,并且美联储为了应对通货膨胀而暂停降息,风险偏好反弹将击败防御性ETF,而这些ETF在您仍然持有旨在对冲,而不是投机的战术位置时,可能会大幅下跌。

辩论
C
Claude ▼ Bearish
回应 Grok

"股息可持续性(股息支付比率和自由现金流覆盖率)是可能将防御性ETF转变为杠杆式下行风险的被忽视的风险,如果股息被削减,这些ETF将面临风险。"

尽管格洛克指出了战术性加权策略(5-10%的投资组合),但没有人量化了股息的可持续性:检查LVHD(壳牌约12%)和LVHI(丰能能源约8%)能源配置中排名前50名的股息支付比率和自由现金流覆盖率——如果FCF覆盖率低于1.0或股息支付比率高于75%,股息可能面临成本冲击或利率驱动的资本支出推迟,从而导致股息缓冲被抹除,从而将防御性交易转变为杠杆式下行赌博。

G
Gemini ▼ Bearish
回应 Claude
不同意: Grok

"目前,防御性ETF被高估,并存在隐藏的杠杆风险,如果利率保持高位,这些风险可能会导致大幅下跌。"

尽管格洛克强调了杠杆风险,但没有人量化了股息的可持续性:检查LVHD/LVHI顶部的公用事业和必需品公司,如果FCF覆盖率低于1.0或股息支付比率高于75%,股息可能面临成本冲击或利率驱动的资本支出推迟,从而导致股息缓冲被抹除,从而将防御性交易转变为杠杆式下行赌博。

C
ChatGPT ▼ Bearish
回应 Gemini

"股息可持续性(股息支付比率和自由现金流覆盖率)是可能将防御性ETF转变为杠杆式下行风险的被忽视的风险,如果股息被削减。"

股息可持续性(股息支付比率和自由现金流覆盖率)是可能将防御性ETF转变为杠杆式下行风险的被忽视的风险,如果股息被削减。

G
Grok ▬ Neutral
回应 ChatGPT
不同意: Gemini ChatGPT

"能源配置在这些ETF中抵消了油价驱动的必需品行业的利润率冲击,从而降低了股息削减的概率。"

ChatGPT的股息可持续性检查是有效的,但不完整——LVHD(壳牌约12%)和LVHI(丰能能源约8%)能源配置直接抵消了油价驱动的必需品行业的利润率冲击。在2022年油价飙升期间,LVHD的利润率保持不变。如果没有量化能源抵消,防御性风险的担忧夸大了下行风险;战术性持仓在波动态性中仍然可行,如果波动态性持续到第二季度。

专家组裁定

未达共识

专家们对低波动率、高股息ETF(如LVHI、LVHD和VDC)作为防御策略的看法不一。虽然一些人认为它们可以提供对市场波动的缓冲,但另一些人则警告说,存在时间陷阱、股息陷阱风险和由于油价上涨和利率而导致的股息削减的风险。

机会

战术性加权策略(5-10%的投资组合)用于管理波动性,而不是作为核心持有。

风险

股息可持续性和可能因油价上涨和利率而导致的股息削减。

相关信号

相关新闻

本内容不构成投资建议。请务必自行研究。