ACIC Stock Snapshot Price, market cap, P/E, EPS, ROE, debt/equity, 52-week range

03
Price $9.33
Market Cap (MRQ) $441M
P/E (TTM) 4.6
EPS (TTM) $2.02
Revenue (TTM) $331M
Div Yield 0.00%
ROE (TTM) 31.7%
52W Range $9–$13

ACIC Stock Price Chart Daily OHLCV with technical indicators — pan, zoom, and customize your view

04
range
bars

Bar granularity adapts to the selected period — hover the chart to see open/high/low/close for a bar.

About American Coastal Insurance Corporation - Common Stock Company overview from Wikipedia

05 · wikidata

United Property & Casualty Insurance Company, Inc. (UPC Insurance) is an American property and casualty insurance company with headquarters in Florida. It writes commercial, residential, homeowners’, and flood insurance policies in several coastal states.

As of 2019, UPC Insurance had about 159,170 active policies, accounting for just over 2.5 percent market share.

## History

UPC Insurance was founded in 1999 in St. Petersburg, Florida.

In 2012, John Forney was named CEO. Forney is a former U.S. Army infantry officer and graduate of Ranger School. Before joining UPC Insurance, he served in several capacities at Raymond James Financial.

In 2014, UPC Insurance purchased the AAA Auto South building, which had been owned by the Peninsula Motor Club Inc. since 1987, as its new headquarters. The company tried to acquire Family Security Holdings LLC but never completed the $9 million deal. Also in 2014, Judy Copechal, Chief Underwriting Officer at UPC Insurance, was named as one of the Top 10 Women in Insurance Leadership by Insurance Networking News.

In 2015, UPC Insurance acquired Interboro Insurance Company, a property and casualty insurance company authorized in New York, Alabama, South Carolina, Washington, D.C., and Louisiana, from Interboro, LLC for $57 million. The company also participated in the Texas Windstorm Insurance Association (TWIA) Depopulation Program.

In 2017, UPC Insurance merged with American Coastal Insurance Co. Journey Insurance Company offers homeowners and commercial residential property insurance through independent agents and brokers in Florida, South Carolina, and Texas. It received an “A−“ Financial Strength Rating and “a-“ Issuer Credit Rating from A.M. Best.

In 2018, UPC Insurance announced plans to build another new headquarters in downtown St. Petersburg, the first new office construction in the area since the Duke Energy Florida headquarters in 2007. The company also collaborated with R.J. Kiln & Co., a subsidiary of Tokio Marine Kiln, to form a property and casualty insurance subsidiary called Journey Insurance Company.

In 2019, UPC Insurance reported first-quarter catastrophe losses of $13 million after-tax due to several catastrophic events, including the Brevard County hailstorm, as well as possible loss creep from Hurricane Irma and Hurricane Michael.

UPC announced in August 2022 that they would leave the Florida Property Insurance market with a plan to cancel all remaining policies May 31, 2023 before the start of the hurricane season on June 1. Hurricane Ian struck Florida the following month near Fort Myers. UPC policies were concentrated in Southwest Florida and the company experienced 25,000 claims. The company initially projected losses of $660 million but by the end of 2022, losses were revised to $864 million.

When UPC notified Florida's Office of Insurance Regulation of their dire financial situation, the Insurance Commissioner sent a letter to CFO Jimmy Patronis to seek court approval to place UPC into receivership. In early February 2023 Slide Insurance assumed 72,000 of the 135,000 UPC policies. Less than a week later, UPC was declared insolvent.

== References ==

Source: Wikipedia, CC BY-SA 4.0 · View on Wikipedia ↗

Wikidata ↗

sectorFinancials industryInsurance employees68 countryUS

10-Year Performance Revenue, net income, margins and EPS trends

06
Revenue$335M
2020-12-31 → 2025-12-31
EPS$2.15
2020-12-31 → 2025-12-31
Free Cash Flow$71M
2020-12-31 → 2025-12-31
Net margin30.3%
2020-12-31 → 2025-12-31
Valuation & Ratios 07–12

Valuation P/E, P/S, P/B, EV/EBITDA ratios — is the stock expensive or cheap?

Metric 5Y trend ACIC 5Y avg Peer Median Verdict
P/E (TTM) 4.65Y avg ≈4.0 ≈4.0 10.5 Undervalued
P/S (TTM) 1.35Y avg ≈1.5 ≈1.5 1.6 Fair value
P/B (MRQ) 1.35Y avg ≈1.8 ≈1.8 1.7 Fair value
Price / FCF (TTM) -14.25Y avg ≈2.0 ≈2.0 · ·
Price / Cash Flow (TTM) -14.45Y avg ≈2.0 ≈2.0 6.4 Pricier
Price / Tangible Book (MRQ) 1.35Y avg ≈3.5 ≈3.5 · ·

Peer median is calculated on a standardized basis per metric and may not always match the TTM/MRQ basis shown for this stock.

value · ≈ 5Y avg · industry median · verdict relative to median

Dividends Yield, payout ratio, dividend history, 5Y CAGR

13
Dividend Yield0.00%
Payout Ratio0.00%
Annualized Payout≈$3.00Paid quarterly
Ex-dateAmountCurrencyYield
Jan 2, 2026$0.75USD≈6.6%
Jan 2, 2025$0.50USD≈3.9%
Mar 8, 2022$0.06USD≈7.0%
Nov 19, 2021$0.06USD≈5.2%
Aug 9, 2021$0.06USD≈6.1%
May 14, 2021$0.06USD≈4.1%
Mar 1, 2021$0.06USD≈3.4%
Nov 20, 2020$0.06USD≈5.2%
Aug 10, 2020$0.06USD≈2.6%
May 18, 2020$0.06USD≈2.9%
Mar 3, 2020$0.06USD≈2.4%
Nov 18, 2019$0.06USD≈1.9%
Aug 13, 2019$0.06USD≈2.1%
May 13, 2019$0.06USD≈1.7%
Mar 5, 2019$0.06USD≈1.5%
Nov 19, 2018$0.06USD≈1.3%
Aug 10, 2018$0.06USD≈1.2%
May 21, 2018$0.06USD≈1.1%
Mar 6, 2018$0.06USD≈1.3%
Nov 21, 2017$0.06USD≈1.5%

Earnings History EPS actual vs estimate, surprise %, beat rate, next earnings date

14
Avg Surprise -5.8%
Next Report Nov 03, 2026
PeriodReportEPS ActualEPS EstSurprise
June 30, 2026 Aug 12, 2026 $0.33 $0.43 -23.0%
March 31, 2026 May 7, 2026 $0.39 $0.45 -13.1%
Dec. 31, 2025 $0.52 $0.43 21.4%
Sept. 30, 2025 $0.61 $0.40 53.3%
June 30, 2025 $0.54 $2.29 -76.5%
March 31, 2025 $0.42 $0.41 2.9%

Full Fundamentals All metrics by year — income statement, balance sheet, cash flow

15
Income Statement 14
Metric Trend 202520242023202220212020201920182017201620152014
Revenue $335M$297M$264M$222M$229M$847M$825M$724M$654M$487M$358M$280M
SG&A Expense $40M$45M$38M$44M$31M$72M$66M$66M$82M$43M$30M$20M
Operating Expenses $195M$197M$171M$230M$239M$979M$858M$728M$28M$21M$15M$12M
Operating Income $140M$100M$94M$-9M$-11M$-132M$-33M$-4M$757.0K$7M$42M$64M
Interest Expense $11M$12M$11M$9M$9M$10M$10M$10M$3M$723.0K$326.0K$410.0K
Other Non-op $2M$2M$2M$10M$129.0K$74.0K$119.0K$116.0K$153.0K$100.0K$294.0K$77.0K
Pretax Income $143M$102M$96M$2M$-10M$-132M$-33M$-4M$910.0K$7M$42M$64M
Income Tax $36M$25M$11M$26M$-7M$-37M$-3M$-5M$-9M$1M$15M$23M
Net Income $107M$76M$310M$-470M$-58M$-96M$-30M$290.0K$10M$6M$27M$41M
EPS (Basic) $2.20$1.59$7.11$-10.91$-1.35$-2.25$-0.70$0.01$0.27$0.27$1.29$2.06
EPS (Diluted) $2.15$1.54$6.98$-10.91$-1.35$-2.25$-0.70$0.01$0.27$0.26$1.28$2.05
Shares (Basic) 48,476,82447,831,41243,596,43243,052,07042,948,85042,864,16642,763,42342,650,62937,152,76821,417,48621,218,23319,933,652
Shares (Diluted) 49,782,99349,362,98544,388,80443,052,07042,948,85042,864,16642,763,42342,838,88637,375,34021,614,44321,452,54020,045,907
EBITDA $144M$104M$91M$-449M$-76M$-126M$-26M$-133.0K$7M·$43M$65M
Balance Sheet 18
Metric Trend 202520242023202220212020201920182017201620152014
Cash & Equivalents $199M$137M$139M$71M$212M$239M$215M$113M$230M$151M$85M$61M
PP&E (Net) $723.0K$6M$4M$5M$32M$34M$33M$17M$17M$18M$17M$8M
PP&E (Gross) $9M$14M$9M$11M$58M$60M$52M$30M$30M$25M$22M$11M
Accum. Depreciation $8M$9M$5M$6M$26M$25M$19M$13M$13M$7M$5M$3M
Goodwill $59M$59M$59M$70M$73M$73M$73M$73M$73M$14M$3M$0
Intangibles $3M$6M$9M$13M$18M$22M$26M$31M$45M$12M$5M·
Total Assets $1.07B$1.22B$1.06B$2.84B$2.70B$2.85B$2.47B$2.32B$2.06B$1000M$740M$584M
Deferred Tax ···$177.0K········
Total Liabilities $755M$980M$894M$3.02B$2.37B$2.43B$1.94B$1.78B$1.52B$758M$501M$380M
Long-term Debt $150M$150M$150M$150M$159M$160M$162M$163M$165M$54M$12M$14M
Common Stock $5.0K$5.0K$5.0K$4.0K$4.0K$4.0K$4.0K$4.0K$4.0K$2.0K$2.0K$2.0K
Paid-in Capital $440M$437M$424M$396M$394M$393M$392M$389M$387M$99M$97M$82M
Retained Earnings $-115M$-185M$-237M$-546M$-75M$-7M$100M$141M$141M$142M$141M$118M
Treasury Stock $431.0K$431.0K$431.0K$431.0K$431.0K$431.0K$431.0K$431.0K$431.0K$431.0K$431.0K$431.0K
AOCI $-7M$-16M$-17M$-31M$-7M$10M$11M$-9M$9M$822.0K$2M$4M
Stockholders' Equity $318M$236M$169M$-182M$332M$396M$503M$520M$537M$241M$239M$204M
Liabilities + Equity $1.07B$1.22B$1.06B$2.84B$2.70B$2.85B$2.47B$2.32B$2.06B$1000M$740M$584M
Shares Outstanding 48,764,80248,204,96246,777,00643,280,17343,370,44243,075,87743,028,07442,984,57842,753,05421,646,61421,524,34820,904,414
Cash Flow 16
Metric Trend 202520242023202220212020201920182017201620152014
D&A $4M$5M$1M$5M$6M$6M$6M$4M$6M$2M$2M$731.0K
Stock-based Comp $4M$3M$1M$1M$1M$1M$3M$2M$3M$2M$2M$649.0K
Amort. of Intangibles $2M$3M$3M$3M$4M$4M$5M$14M$31M$11M$3M$460.0K
Other Non-cash $-44M$160M$-449M$289M$-247M$78M$170M$3M$-4M·$67M$27M
Operating Cash Flow $71M$244M$-136M$-173M$-295M$-10M$149M$26M$36M$66M$98M$69M
CapEx $155.0K$22.0K$196.0K$3M$5M$11M$22M$4M$5M$3M$11M$6M
Investing Cash Flow $620.0K$-179M$-3M$237M$251M$37M$-34M$-126M$-7M$-50M$-67M$-91M
Debt Issued ······$0$0$150M$35M$0$0
Net Debt Issued ···$-4M$-2M$-1M$-2M$-2M$110M·$-3M$-1M
Stock Issued $774.0K$12M$27M$0·····$0$0$54M
Net Stock Activity $774.0K$12M$27M·······$0$54M
Dividends Paid $0$24M$0$3M$10M$10M$10M$10M$9M$5M$4M$3M
Financing Cash Flow $-1M$-14M$27M$-25M$-12M$-12M$-12M$8M$97M$50M$-8M$49M
Net Change in Cash ········$126M$66M$23M$27M
Free Cash Flow $71M$243M$-136M$-176M$-301M$-21M$127M$6M$9M·$87M$63M
Levered FCF $63M$234M$-146M$-186M$-307M$-28M$118M$7M$-27M·$87M$62M
Profitability 7
Metric Trend 202520242023202220212020201920182017201620152014
Operating Margin 41.8%33.6%31.3%-99.9%-13.2%-15.6%-4.0%-0.60%0.12%·11.6%23.0%
Net Margin 31.9%25.5%108.2%-103.2%-9.1%-11.4%-3.6%0.04%1.6%·7.6%14.6%
Pretax Margin 42.5%34.3%32.1%-97.6%-13.2%-15.6%-4.0%-0.59%0.14%·11.7%23.0%
EBITDA Margin 43.0%35.2%31.9%-98.5%-12.0%-14.8%-3.2%-0.02%1.0%·12.1%23.2%
ROA 9.3%6.7%15.9%-23.7%-1.9%-3.6%-1.2%0.01%0.66%·4.1%8.0%
ROE 35.0%30.6%214.2%924.9%-16.4%-21.5%-5.8%0.05%2.6%·12.3%26.4%
ROIC 33.1%31.7%47.5%264.2%-19.2%-24.1%-5.9%0.08%1.6%·11.4%20.1%
Liquidity & Solvency 1
Metric Trend 202520242023202220212020201920182017201620152014
Interest Coverage 13.08.38.3-47.3-8.9-13.8-3.3-0.40.2·127.5156.9
Efficiency 1
Metric Trend 202520242023202220212020201920182017201620152014
Asset Turnover 0.30.30.10.20.20.30.30.30.4·0.50.5
Per Share 6
Metric Trend 202520242023202220212020201920182017201620152014
Book Value / Share $6.51$4.89$3.61$-4.21$7.20$9.19$11.69$12.10$12.56·$11.11$9.75
Revenue / Share $6.74$6.01$6.46$10.58$14.77$19.75$19.29$16.90$17.51·$16.67$13.98
Cash Flow / Share $1.43$4.93$-3.06$-4.02$-6.88$-0.24$3.48$0.24$0.38·$4.58$3.44
Cash / Share $4.08··$5.31$4.89$5.56$5.01$2.62$6.46·$3.94$2.94
Dividend / Share $0.75$0.50······$0.24$0.23$0.20$0.16
EPS (TTM) $2.15$1.54$6.98$-10.91$-1.35$-2.25$-0.70$0.01$0.27$0.26$1.28$2.05
Growth Rates 5
Metric Trend 202520242023202220212020201920182017201620152014
Revenue YoY 13.1%12.2%19.3%-3.1%-73.0%·······
Revenue CAGR 3Y 14.8%9.1%-32.1%·········
Revenue CAGR 5Y -16.9%···········
EPS YoY 39.6%-77.9%··········
Net Income YoY 41.1%-75.6%··········
Valuation (TTM) 13
Metric Trend 202520242023202220212020201920182017201620152014
Revenue TTM $335M$297M$264M$222M$229M$847M$825M$724M$654M$487M$358M$280M
Net Income TTM $107M$76M$310M$-470M$-58M$-96M$-30M$290.0K$10M$6M$27M$41M
Market Cap $616M$649M$443M$46M$188M$246M$543M$714M$737M·$368M$459M
P/E 5.98.71.4-0.1-3.2-2.5-18.01662.063.958.213.410.7
P/S 1.82.21.70.20.80.30.71.01.1·1.01.6
P/B 1.92.82.6-0.30.60.61.11.41.4·1.52.3
P / Tangible Book 2.43.84.4·0.80.8······
P / Cash Flow 8.72.7-3.3-0.3-0.6-23.53.670.651.5·3.76.7
P / FCF 8.72.7-3.2-0.3-0.6-11.64.3118.181.3·4.27.3
Dividend Yield 0.00%3.7%0.00%5.6%5.5%4.2%1.9%1.4%1.2%·1.2%0.73%
Earnings Yield 17.0%11.4%73.8%-1029.2%-31.1%-39.3%-5.5%0.06%1.6%1.7%7.5%9.3%
Payout Ratio 0.00%31.8%·-0.55%-17.9%-10.7%-34.4%3540.7%88.6%·15.7%8.1%
Annual Payout $0$24M$0$3M$10M$10M$10M$10M$9M$5M$4M$3M

Most recent period on the left · null values shown as ·

Financial Statements Income statement, balance sheet, cash flow — annual, last 5 years

16
Metric 2025-12-312024-12-312023-12-312022-12-312022-03-31
Revenue $335M $297M $264M $222M ·
Operating Margin % 41.8% 33.6% 31.3% -99.9% ·
Net Income $107M $76M $310M $-470M ·
Diluted EPS $2.15 $1.54 $6.98 $-10.91 ·

Institutional owners (13F) 144 filers · $182.6M total · As of Sept. 30, 2026

17

Institutions that report holding this stock in their quarterly SEC Form 13F. Long positions only; a single filer may appear twice for separate option legs. Large offsetting put/call legs typically reflect market-making or hedged inventory, not directional conviction.

Holders 144
Value held $182.6M
New positions 18
Exited positions 32
Institutional activity — Q2 2026 vs prior quarter
New positions Exited positions Increased Decreased Net shares change
18 (-25 vs prior Q) 32 (+12 vs prior Q) 47 (-5 vs prior Q) 38 (0 vs prior Q) -2.2M

Compared to Q1 2026. SEC Form 13F filings are due within 45 days of quarter-end plus a short buffer for late filers — quarters still inside that window are skipped in favor of the most recent fully-reported pair.

Institution Value Shares % of tracked 13F Type
BlackRock, Inc. $25,308,722 2,280,065 13.86% Shares
VANGUARD GROUP INC $17,084,285 1,352,675 9.36% Shares
VANGUARD CAPITAL MANAGEMENT LLC $11,051,560 995,636 6.05% Shares
DIMENSIONAL FUND ADVISORS LP $9,920,943 893,772 5.43% Shares
AMERICAN CENTURY COMPANIES INC $9,416,874 848,367 5.16% Shares
PUNCH & ASSOCIATES INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT, INC. $8,976,625 808,705 4.92% Shares
GEODE CAPITAL MANAGEMENT, LLC $7,516,850 677,070 4.12% Shares
TWO SIGMA INVESTMENTS, LP $6,566,249 591,554 3.60% Shares
RENAISSANCE TECHNOLOGIES LLC $6,020,185 542,359 3.30% Shares
STATE STREET CORP $5,658,414 509,767 3.10% Shares
ARROWSTREET CAPITAL, LIMITED PARTNERSHIP $5,056,894 455,576 2.77% Shares
BRIDGEWAY CAPITAL MANAGEMENT, LLC $3,374,866 304,042 1.85% Shares
SEI INVESTMENTS CO $3,206,912 288,911 1.76% Shares
Empowered Funds, LLC $2,991,816 269,533 1.64% Shares
AQR CAPITAL MANAGEMENT LLC $2,798,195 252,090 1.53% Shares
VANGUARD PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT LLC $2,657,129 239,381 1.46% Shares
Empyrean Capital Partners, LP $2,562,735 230,877 1.40% Shares
Militia Capital Partners, LP $2,281,711 180,658 1.25% Shares
NORTHERN TRUST CORP $2,216,038 199,643 1.21% Shares
Crews Bank & Trust $2,098,733 189,075 1.15% Shares
GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP INC $2,084,502 187,793 1.14% Shares
TUDOR INVESTMENT CORP ET AL $2,069,129 186,408 1.13% Shares
VANGUARD FIDUCIARY TRUST CO $1,807,258 162,816 0.99% Shares
WESTWOOD HOLDINGS GROUP INC $1,650,959 148,735 0.90% Shares
Kennondale Capital Management LLC $1,629,280 146,782 0.89% Shares
MERCER GLOBAL ADVISORS INC /ADV $1,492,428 134,453 0.82% Shares
O'SHAUGHNESSY ASSET MANAGEMENT, LLC $1,476,034 132,976 0.81% Shares
Brandywine Global Investment Management, LLC $1,407,866 111,470 0.77% Shares
Connor, Clark & Lunn Investment Management Ltd. $1,360,672 122,583 0.75% Shares
FRANKLIN RESOURCES INC $1,261,737 113,670 0.69% Shares
ANTIPODES PARTNERS Ltd $1,256,342 113,184 0.69% Shares
Bank of New York Mellon Corp $1,046,125 94,246 0.57% Shares
Lido Advisors, LLC $985,333 88,768 0.54% Shares
RITHOLTZ WEALTH MANAGEMENT $956,332 86,156 0.52% Shares
WEDGE CAPITAL MANAGEMENT L L P/NC $942,480 83,776 0.52% Shares
MACKENZIE FINANCIAL CORP $919,513 82,839 0.50% Shares
FIRST TRUST ADVISORS LP $899,199 81,009 0.49% Shares
JACOBS LEVY EQUITY MANAGEMENT, INC $861,626 77,624 0.47% Shares
RAYMOND JAMES FINANCIAL INC $828,637 74,652 0.45% Shares
CHARLES SCHWAB INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT INC $827,039 74,508 0.45% Shares
Pacific Ridge Capital Partners, LLC $826,761 74,483 0.45% Shares
BANK OF AMERICA CORP /DE/ $814,152 73,347 0.45% Shares
Cubist Systematic Strategies, LLC $777,310 68,245 0.43% Shares
MORGAN STANLEY $767,931 69,183 0.42% Shares
Beacon Pointe Advisors, LLC $754,301 67,955 0.41% Shares
Nuveen, LLC $752,180 67,764 0.41% Shares
Quantinno Capital Management LP $702,963 63,330 0.38% Shares
TWO SIGMA ADVISERS, LP $678,231 53,700 0.37% Shares
JANE STREET GROUP, LLC $672,749 60,608 0.37% Shares
Tactive Advisors, LLC $610,667 55,015 0.33% Shares

Show all 144 institutional owners →

Activists & 5%+ owners 11 positions

18

Investors who filed SEC Schedule 13D — beneficial ownership above 5% with an intent to influence the issuer (activist stakes, board campaigns, M&A). Each row shows the most recent known state of that filer's position.

Filer Filed Stake Status Purpose Filing
Peed Daniel, Peed FLP1, Ltd, L.L.P. ×2 filings Aug. 11, 2025 34.50% Amendment · SEC
R. Daniel Peed, Peed FLP1 Ltd, L.L.P. ×3 filings March 20, 2019 · Initial filing · SEC
Stilwell Value Partners I, L.P., Stilwell Value Partners VI, L.P., Stilwell Associates, L.P., Stilwell Associates Insurance Fund of the S.A.L.I. Multi-Series Fund L.P., Stilwell Value LLC, Stilwell Advisers LLC, Joseph Stilwell ×2 filings Dec. 17, 2012 · Initial filing Board campaign SEC
Undisclosed reporting person, Undisclosed reporting person, Undisclosed reporting person Sept. 20, 2012 · Initial filing · SEC
Stilwell Value Partners VI, L.P., Stilwell Associates, L.P., Stilwell Associates Insurance Fund of the S.A.L.I. Multi-Series Fund L.P., Stilwell Value LLC, Stilwell Advisers LLC, Joseph Stilwell ×2 filings May 29, 2012 · Initial filing Board campaign SEC
Neil W. Savage, Kern M. Davis, William W. Hood, III ×4 filings March 15, 2012 · Initial filing · SEC
Undisclosed reporting person, Undisclosed reporting person, Undisclosed reporting person Oct. 28, 2011 · Initial filing Passive investment SEC
Synovus Financial Corp. ×5 filings Sept. 30, 2011 · Initial filing · SEC
Homeowners Choice, Inc. ×2 filings Dec. 9, 2010 · Initial filing · SEC
Bulldog Investors, Phillip Goldstein and Andrew Dakos ×3 filings Nov. 12, 2008 · Initial filing · SEC
Gregory C. Branch Oct. 15, 2008 · Initial filing · SEC

Purpose is an automated classification of the filer's own stated purpose (SEC Item 4) — not investment advice. "—" means no clear purpose was stated or the text could not be classified.

Company insiders 42 insiders · 21 officers · 15 directors

19
Insider Role Last activity Shares owned Buys 12m Sells 12m Net 12m
Brad Martz President & CEO Sept. 22, 2026 P 444,611 1 0 $91,500
John Forney President & CEO May 26, 2020 A 124,491 0 0 $0
Svetlana Castle Chief Financial Officer May 12, 2026 A 16,390 0 0 $0
Nicholas W Griffin Chief Financial Officer March 25, 2009 A 58,310 0 0 $0
Christopher Griffith Chief Operating Officer Aug. 17, 2026 M 118,724 0 3 $-610,245
Paul F Difrancesco Chief Operating Officer Aug. 18, 2020 A 20,533 0 0 $0
Brooke Adler Secretary Sept. 24, 2026 S 100,175 0 1 $-192,036
Troy J Crawford Chief Underwriting Officer July 15, 2026 F 12,107 1 0 $35,456
James Andy Gray Chief Compliance/Risk Officer May 12, 2026 A 207,504 0 0 $0
Brooke Shirazi Chief Underwriting Officer May 27, 2022 A 112,000 0 0 $0
Alycia Weigley Chief Talent Officer May 27, 2022 A 9,002 0 0 $0
Scott St John Chief Claims Officer May 27, 2022 A 25,140 0 0 $0
Christian Dittman Chief Risk Officer May 24, 2021 A 20,238 0 0 $0
Brad Kalter Chief Legal Officer Nov. 30, 2020 A 661 0 0 $0
Deepak Menon Chief Revenue Officer Sept. 18, 2020 M 102,787 0 0 $0
Kimberly Salmon General Counsel Sept. 7, 2017 P 29,622 0 0 $0
Andrew Swenson Chief Information Officer May 12, 2017 P 31,017 0 0 $0
John Langowski Vice President, Claims March 18, 2016 F 14,659 0 0 $0
Judy Copechal Chief Underwriting Officer May 6, 2015 P 3,327 0 0 $0
Jay Williams Vice President of Sales Feb. 24, 2015 A 17,615 0 0 $0
Melvin A Russell Jr Chief Underwriting Officer Dec. 11, 2012 P 49,018 0 0 $0
Patrick Maroney Director May 26, 2026 A 103,500 0 0 $0
Daniel Peed Director May 26, 2026 A 1,986,936 0 0 $0
Iii William H. Hood Director May 26, 2026 A 65,429 0 0 $0
Kern Michael Davis Director May 26, 2026 A 304,564 8 0 $27,548
Deirdre A Brown Director May 26, 2026 A 6,500 0 0 $0
Gregory C Branch Director May 26, 2026 A 1,729,197 0 0 $0
Kent G Whittemore Director May 26, 2026 A 374,267 0 0 $0
Michael Hogan Director May 26, 2026 A 366,754 0 0 $0
Alec Poitevint II Director May 26, 2026 A 195,000 0 0 $0
Sherrill W Hudson Director May 19, 2025 A 203,403 0 0 $0
Gordon G Pratt Director Oct. 6, 2008 P 932,231 0 0 $0
David E Sturgess Director Sept. 30, 2008 D 17,839 0 0 $0
Thomas D Sargent Director Sept. 30, 2008 D 17,839 0 0 $0
James Zuhlke Director Sept. 30, 2008 D 17,839 0 0 $0
Stilwell Value LLC 10% owner Oct. 22, 2012 S 49,318 0 0 $0
Stilwell Joseph 10% owner Oct. 22, 2012 S 49,318 0 0 $0
Neil W Savage 10% owner Sept. 28, 2011 P 17,573 0 0 $0
SYNOVUS FINANCIAL CORP 10% owner Sept. 28, 2011 S 220,047 0 0 $0
FMG INVESTORS LLC 10% owner Sept. 30, 2008 D 932,231 0 0 $0
Donald J Cronin · March 25, 2009 A 91,351 0 0 $0
Larry G Swets JR · Oct. 22, 2008 P 932,231 0 0 $0

Insiders from SEC Form 3/4/5 filings; net = open-market P/S only

ETF ownership Held by 23 ETFs

20

Weight reflects direct equity holdings (N-PORT) only; leveraged or derivative-based funds may hold additional swap exposure not shown.

Fund Weight Units As of Source
IWC · iShares Trust 0.06% 86,791 SH Sept. 11, 2026 Daily
VFQY · VANGUARD WELLINGTON FUND 0.05% 19,491 SH Aug. 19, 2026 Daily
VTWV · VANGUARD SCOTTSDALE FUNDS 0.02% 21,955 SH Aug. 19, 2026 Daily
OMFS · Invesco Exchange-Traded Self-Indexe… 0.02% 5,568 SH Oct. 2, 2026 Daily
DFAS · Dimensional ETF Trust 0.01% 161,437 NS July 31, 2026 N-PORT
VTWO · VANGUARD SCOTTSDALE FUNDS 0.01% 145,239 SH Aug. 19, 2026 Daily
IWM · iShares Trust 0.01% 827,803 SH Sept. 11, 2026 Daily
RSSL · Global X Funds 0.01% 12,028 NS July 31, 2026 N-PORT
DFAT · Dimensional ETF Trust 0.01% 76,937 NS July 31, 2026 N-PORT
DFSU · Dimensional ETF Trust 0.00% 9,019 NS July 31, 2026 N-PORT
DXUV · Dimensional ETF Trust 0.00% 1,293 NS July 31, 2026 N-PORT
DCOR · Dimensional ETF Trust 0.00% 6,441 NS July 31, 2026 N-PORT
DFAU · Dimensional ETF Trust 0.00% 13,739 NS July 31, 2026 N-PORT
DFAC · Dimensional ETF Trust 0.00% 37,406 NS July 31, 2026 N-PORT
IWV · iShares Trust 0.00% 12,213 SH Sept. 3, 2026 Daily
DFUS · Dimensional ETF Trust 0.00% 4,888 NS July 31, 2026 N-PORT
VXF · VANGUARD INDEX FUNDS 0.00% 284,795 SH Aug. 19, 2026 Daily
VTI · VANGUARD INDEX FUNDS 0.00% 688,548 SH Aug. 19, 2026 Daily
VTHR · VANGUARD SCOTTSDALE FUNDS 0.00% 2,292 SH Aug. 19, 2026 Daily
DFUV · Dimensional ETF Trust 0.00% 44 NS July 31, 2026 N-PORT
VFH · VANGUARD WORLD FUND 0.00% 39,296 SH Aug. 19, 2026 Daily
IWN · iShares Trust · 275,336 SH Sept. 11, 2026 Daily
SVAL · iShares Trust · 51,032 SH Sept. 3, 2026 Daily

ACIC Analyst Consensus Bullish and bearish analyst opinions, 12-month price target, upside

21
rating · 8 analysts BUY
Median target $13.00 +39.3%
2 25.0% Strong Buy
4 50.0% Buy
2 25.0% Hold
0 0.0% Sell
0 0.0% Strong Sell

12-Month Price Target

1 analysts · 2026-09-15

Mean target $13.00 +39.3%

Low$13.00 Mean$13.00 High$13.00

Peer comparison (GICS sub-industry) Key metrics vs sector peers

22

FY basis, prices as of each company's last fiscal year-end close.

Ticker Market Cap P/E Rev YoY Net Margin ROE Gross Margin
ACIC $616M 5.9 13.1% 31.9% 35.0% ·
ROOT · 30.6 28.9% 2.7% 15.2% ·
DGICA · · -1.2% 8.1% 12.7% ·
TIPT $691M 24.0 -67.9% 7157.2% 7.2% ·
ITIC $471M 13.4 5.6% 12.9% 13.2% ·
AII $408M 3.7 35.3% 36.0% 31.2% ·
AMSF $722M 15.6 2.7% 14.9% 18.2% ·
GBLI · 16.2 2.0% 5.6% 3.6% ·
NODK $273M -26.6 -12.3% -3.6% -4.3% 24.5%
KWY · · · · · ·
KINS $242M 5.8 38.5% 19.0% 37.5% ·

My Metrics Your personal watchlist — selected rows from Full Fundamentals

26

Pick the metrics that matter to you — click the + next to any row in Full Fundamentals above.

Your selection is saved and follows you across all tickers.

Source: SEC 10-Q filed Aug 6, 2026